Blogrolls or not?

…Certain behaviors are rewarded with links in weblogging; certain behaviors are not. It’s just that a certain class of weblogger (white, male, Western, educated, charismatic, pugnacious) has defined the ‘winning’ behavior in weblogging and what must be done to ‘earn’ a link, and this is what we need to change, if change it we can. We have to start valuing the poet, the teenage girl, the middle aged gardener, as much as we value the pundits, whether political or technological.

Bottom line: I want to be respected, I want to be heard, I want to be seen. I want to be visible, but I don’t want to be you.

But I digress, and badly. I’ve been chastized on this in the past, and how I am taking much of this personally. “But”?, I respond, blinking in puzzlement, “It is personal.”? Still, this was about blogrolls and whether to drop them or not, and how this could impact on the hotshot lists and will this end up making everything better – or, at least, more equal.

My short answer is: I don’t know.

Burningbird: Ms Pancake

Read it and think.

She may claim not to know, but she gives thought provoking points for keeping or removing them. Do blogrolls contribute to less voices being heard? Do they encourage the worst or best in us?

For the longest time I had my personal blogroll off the front page of the site. I’m now convinced to put it back there, along with my favorite links. I feel, however, that in some cases, blogrolls can help solidify and surface communities and are a very important tool to do so.

Related: rebecca blood reflecting on her idealism. via dangerousmeta.

This just in to Groundhog Day World Headquarters….

Brahahahaha: “Long-tail webloggers, Dave Rogers, Al Hawkins and Doug Miller today met for an emergent, flat, virtual conference using the multi-person audio chat facility built into Apple’s flat-world dominating Tiger OS.” read the rest.

There’s some truth to that buzzword-ridden sentence 🙂

Related: Chris Anderson reveals the origins of identifying “The Long Tail”.

The Huffington Post and News & Observer Blogs launch

Two efforts to turn media on its head have launched these past couple weeks that deserve more mention: The Huffington Post will feature an interesting mix of celebrities and commentators while News & Observer publishing (a Knight Ridder company publishing four newspapers in the North Carolina Triangle area) launches a Philly Future like effort allowing the community to take part in reporting what’s important to them.

Philadelphia Daily News launches first city newspaper podcast in nation

I…err… think that’s the case. Anyway – they are definitely first among this region’s papers. Check out PhillyFeed. The first podcast is kinda like NPR… but with attytood.

Speaking of Attytood, the podcast and Will Bunch’s blog make the Daily News among the most forward thinking, risk taking newspapers online in the region and beyond.

It’s RealCities vs MSN Sidewalk vs AOL Digital Cities all over again

A growing number of efforts are joining Philly Future in attempting to provide tools their local community can use to communicate, share news, and connect.

Backfence.com‘s launch, in particular, has raised a stir from folks in various corners of the web.

Dan Gillmor: Backfence Launches

A VC: Hyperlocal – Backfence vs 101

Jay Rosen: More on the Migration: Developments and Sightings

Steve Outing: Citizen-Journalism Site Backfence Debuts

An editted repost of a comment I left at “A VC”:

I feel Roland Tanglao’s efforts at Bryght are very important: they show just how far barriers have gone down and infrastructures have gone up that enable anyone with little technical know how, or money, to start a site these capabilities.

I run Philly Future (http://www.phillyfuture.org) on a related toolset (CivicSpace) to what Bryght provides – and I have ran it with a small team of volunteers for a very, very long time (various incarnations since 1999 – community aggregator since January 2004 – open participation since mid 2004).

We feature the headlines of over a 100 regional blogs and feeds, and encourage direct, original works to be published to the site – it’s an effort to provide service to our community much like that of the other great sites mentioned here. Very similar to the 101s (which I love as Roch Smith – their founder – knows), but with a slightly different model: While we provide a river of news aggregator – the focus for us is editorializing our regional web – their focus is a pure representation of the community via it’s river of news.

It’s great to see so many other efforts exploring this space now. It recalls the Sidewalk/Digital Cities/RealCities portals larger companies pursued a few years back. The crucial difference is the flow reversal: It’s the communities themselves who are being empowered to determine what is the news and become collective owners of these sites.

Compliments to NowPublic as well – I think they are helping explore and build the infrastructure for distributed journalism.